Related News
Home » Opinion » Chinese Views
Looted relics and China's dilemma
By Fu Shuangqi and Chang Ailing |
February 18, 2009, Wednesday
|
Print Edition
Print Edition
TWO bronze animal sculptures, looted from a Chinese royal garden 149 years ago, will be auctioned in Paris this month.
They symbolize a dilemma China is facing in retrieving many of its cultural treasures from abroad.
The relic looted from Yuanmingyuan "belong" to the Pierre-Berge-Yves Saint Laurent Foundation.
"We wrote to Mr Pierre Berge in October last year after learning the two sculptures will be auctioned but did not receive any reply yet," said Niu Xianfeng, deputy director of the National Treasure Funds of China (NTFC), a non-governmental organization working since 2002 to return the country's historical relics.
Niu's foundation was willing to negotiate with the owner on how to bring the two sculptures back to China on the condition they would not be auctioned.
The bronze rabbit and rat heads were among 12 animal head sculptures that formed the zodiacal clepsydra (water clock) decorating the Calm Sea Pavilion in the Old Summer Palace of Emperor Qianlong (1736-1795). They were looted when the palace was burned down by Anglo-French allied forces during the Second Opium War in 1860.
The NTFC successfully mediated the return of one of the heads in 2003. With about 7 million yuan (US$1.01 million), donated by Macao billionaire Stanley Ho, the foundation bought the pig head sculpture from a US collector.
In 2003, the NTFC contacted representatives of the owner to buy the rabbit and rat head sculptures but the two sides failed to reach an agreement on the price.
"They asked for US$10 million for each but we only spent about 1 million on the pig head. We thought the price was too high," Niu said. At the upcoming auction, the relics were expected to fetch 8 million to 10 million euros (about US$10.4 million to US$13 million) each.
Private purchases
Unlike the NTFC, which does not purchase from auctions, some Chinese collectors have been able to buy cultural artifacts and bring them back to the country. Three animal head sculptures were purchased by a Chinese company at two auctions held by Christie's and Sotheby's in Hong Kong in 2000.
Despite those efforts, China's State Administration of Cultural Heritage (SACH) openly voiced its objection to both auctions and purchases of cultural objects, which were exported illegally, including those looted in wars.
Song Xinchao, director of the SACH museum department, said authorities favored retrieving looted cultural relics through legal or diplomatic proceedings but also welcomed donations from foreign collectors.
"To buy them back means we acknowledge they were taken out of our country legally," Song told the Guangming Daily last November. "It will be a compromise to the wrong thing and even an indulgence in crimes."
Legal and diplomatic retrieval is based on several international conventions China signed, including the 1970 UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property and the 1995 Unidroit Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Objects.
The fact that the conventions could not be applied retroactively was a major obstacle to such legal proceedings, said Wang Yunxia, a professor of cultural relics law at Beijing-based Renmin University.
About 1.64 million Chinese relics are owned by foreign museums, SACH said. Even more are owned by private collectors. A great number were looted out of China between the 1860s and 1949, when the country was subjected to colonial invasion and civil wars.
(The authors are Xinhua writers.)
They symbolize a dilemma China is facing in retrieving many of its cultural treasures from abroad.
The relic looted from Yuanmingyuan "belong" to the Pierre-Berge-Yves Saint Laurent Foundation.
"We wrote to Mr Pierre Berge in October last year after learning the two sculptures will be auctioned but did not receive any reply yet," said Niu Xianfeng, deputy director of the National Treasure Funds of China (NTFC), a non-governmental organization working since 2002 to return the country's historical relics.
Niu's foundation was willing to negotiate with the owner on how to bring the two sculptures back to China on the condition they would not be auctioned.
The bronze rabbit and rat heads were among 12 animal head sculptures that formed the zodiacal clepsydra (water clock) decorating the Calm Sea Pavilion in the Old Summer Palace of Emperor Qianlong (1736-1795). They were looted when the palace was burned down by Anglo-French allied forces during the Second Opium War in 1860.
The NTFC successfully mediated the return of one of the heads in 2003. With about 7 million yuan (US$1.01 million), donated by Macao billionaire Stanley Ho, the foundation bought the pig head sculpture from a US collector.
In 2003, the NTFC contacted representatives of the owner to buy the rabbit and rat head sculptures but the two sides failed to reach an agreement on the price.
"They asked for US$10 million for each but we only spent about 1 million on the pig head. We thought the price was too high," Niu said. At the upcoming auction, the relics were expected to fetch 8 million to 10 million euros (about US$10.4 million to US$13 million) each.
Private purchases
Unlike the NTFC, which does not purchase from auctions, some Chinese collectors have been able to buy cultural artifacts and bring them back to the country. Three animal head sculptures were purchased by a Chinese company at two auctions held by Christie's and Sotheby's in Hong Kong in 2000.
Despite those efforts, China's State Administration of Cultural Heritage (SACH) openly voiced its objection to both auctions and purchases of cultural objects, which were exported illegally, including those looted in wars.
Song Xinchao, director of the SACH museum department, said authorities favored retrieving looted cultural relics through legal or diplomatic proceedings but also welcomed donations from foreign collectors.
"To buy them back means we acknowledge they were taken out of our country legally," Song told the Guangming Daily last November. "It will be a compromise to the wrong thing and even an indulgence in crimes."
Legal and diplomatic retrieval is based on several international conventions China signed, including the 1970 UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property and the 1995 Unidroit Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Objects.
The fact that the conventions could not be applied retroactively was a major obstacle to such legal proceedings, said Wang Yunxia, a professor of cultural relics law at Beijing-based Renmin University.
About 1.64 million Chinese relics are owned by foreign museums, SACH said. Even more are owned by private collectors. A great number were looted out of China between the 1860s and 1949, when the country was subjected to colonial invasion and civil wars.
(The authors are Xinhua writers.)
- About Us
- |
- Terms of Use
- |
-
RSS - |
- Privacy Policy
- |
- Contact Us
- |
- Shanghai Call Center: 962288
- |
- Tip-off hotline: 52920043
- 沪ICP证：沪ICP备05050403号-1
- |
- 互联网新闻信息服务许可证：31120180004
- |
- 网络视听许可证：0909346
- |
- 广播电视节目制作许可证：沪字第354号
- |
- 增值电信业务经营许可证：沪B2-20120012
Copyright © 1999- Shanghai Daily. All rights reserved.Preferably viewed with Internet Explorer 8 or newer browsers.
