Home 禄 Opinion 禄 Foreign Views
It pays to channel funds toward basic research
Print Edition
Government-funded scientific research runs the gamut from studies of basic physical and biological processes to the development of applications to meet immediate needs. Given limited resources, grant-making authorities are tempted to channel a higher proportion of funds toward the latter.
And, faced with today鈥檚 tight budget constraints, the inclination to favor projects that have demonstrable short-term returns is arguably stronger now than in the past. But to succumb to it is a mistake.
Some of science鈥檚 most useful breakthroughs have come as a result of sustained investment in basic research or as by-products of unrelated efforts.
Indeed, evaluating the impact of any research project is difficult. As Marc Kirschner, a professor at Harvard Medical School, pointed out in a thoughtful editorial in the journal Science: 鈥淥ne may be able to recognize good science as it happens, but significant science can only be viewed in the rear-view mirror.鈥
Even preeminent researchers may underestimate the significance of their findings at the time they obtain them.
When Salvador Luria, my university microbiology professor, received the 1969 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine, he made the point eloquently, sending a humorous cartoon to all who had congratulated him on the award. It depicted an elderly couple at the breakfast table. The husband, reading the morning newspaper, exclaims, 鈥淕reat Scott! I鈥檝e been awarded the Nobel Prize for something I seem to have said, or done, or thought, in 1934!鈥
In a 2011 editorial, the French biologist Francois Jacob described the research that led to his 1965 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. His lab had been working on the mechanism that under certain circumstances causes the bacterium E. coli suddenly to produce bacterial viruses. At the same time, another research group was analyzing, also in E. coli, how the synthesis of a certain enzyme is induced in the presence of a specific sugar.
As Jacob put it, 鈥淭he two systems appeared mechanistically miles apart. But their juxtaposition would produce a critical breakthrough for our understanding of life.鈥 Thus was born the concept of an 鈥渙peron,鈥 a cluster of genes whose expression is regulated by an adjacent regulatory gene.
In his editorial, Kirschner bemoaned the 鈥渢endency to equate significance to any form of medical relevance,鈥 noting that it caused research into non-mammalian systems to be treated 鈥渁s intrinsically less valuable than studies on human cells.鈥 As a result, simple but informative model systems can be overlooked, and an important link between basic science and human medicine can be lost.
The past century of research on various non-mammalian model systems makes this point persuasively. For example, studies of Caenorhabditis elegans, a tiny roundworm, have provided a wealth of information on cellular differentiation, neural networks, meiosis, and programmed cell death. Studies of the fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, have significantly advanced our understanding of the mechanisms underlying Mendelian genetics.
The amount of money funneled by governments into research is large. In the United States, the National Institutes of Health spends roughly US$30 billion a year, and the National Science Foundation adds another US$7 billion. As officials decide how that money is to be spent, they would be wise to glance in the rear-view mirror and fund the basic research that keeps science moving forward.
Henry I. Miller is the Robert Wesson Fellow in Scientific Philosophy and Public Policy at Stanford University鈥檚 Hoover Institution. A physician and molecular biologist, he was the founding director of the Office of Biotechnology at the US Food and Drug Administration. Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2015.www.project-syndicate.org. Shanghai Daily condensed the article.
- About Us
- |
- Terms of Use
- |
-
RSS - |
- Privacy Policy
- |
- Contact Us
- |
- Shanghai Call Center: 962288
- |
- Tip-off hotline: 52920043
- 娌狪CP璇侊細娌狪CP澶05050403鍙-1
- |
- 浜掕仈缃戞柊闂讳俊鎭湇鍔¤鍙瘉锛31120180004
- |
- 缃戠粶瑙嗗惉璁稿彲璇侊細0909346
- |
- 骞挎挱鐢佃鑺傜洰鍒朵綔璁稿彲璇侊細娌瓧绗354鍙
- |
- 澧炲肩數淇′笟鍔＄粡钀ヨ鍙瘉锛氭勃B2-20120012
Copyright 漏 1999- Shanghai Daily. All rights reserved.Preferably viewed with Internet Explorer 8 or newer browsers.
